Cross-Border Commercial Disputes And Enforcement Gap: Analysis Of India’s Non- Ratification Of The Singapore Convention On Mediation Vis-A-Vis Mediation Act 2023
Inika Gupta, O.P. Jindal Global University
ABSTRACT
India signed the Singapore Convention on Mediation on the day it opened, yet the Mediation Act, 2023 applies only to mediations conducted in India, and its enforcement provisions have not commenced. This paper argues that the omission reflects a structural choice. The Act borrows the territorial template of Part I of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and leaves out any counterpart to Part II’s regime for foreign awards. That template conflicts with a Convention drafted to be indifferent to where mediation takes place. Comparing India with the United States, China, the European Union, Singapore and Japan, the paper shows that India faces none of the structural obstacles behind others’ hesitation, which makes its non- ratification a deliberate deferral. The consequences fall on inbound parties. Foreign holders of settlements against Indian assets have no treaty route and are pushed towards arbitration. Even after the Act will fully commence, it would still not provide any entry point for foreign settlements, no aligned defences, no recognition abroad for Indian settlements and no enforcement procedure. This paper proposes a dedicated implementing statute containing the definition of internationality in functional terms, enacts the Article 5 defences without additions and manages exposure through reservations.
Keywords: Singapore Convention on Mediation; Mediation Act 2023; Treaty implementation; Mediated Settlement agreements; Cross-border enforcement of settlements.
