The Asymmetric Overlap: Resolving Statutory Inconsistencies Between Copyright Ownership And Device Mark Registrations In India
Manasa R.V.
ABSTRACT
A logo can be considered both as an artistic work, thereby falling within the purview of protection under the Copyright Act, 1957 and as a device mark, thereby falling within the purview of protection under the Trade Marks Act, 1999. This issue has been understood by legal scholars for a long time. The provisions provided under section 45(1) of the Copyright Act mandates searching of the Trade Marks Registry to obtain a certificate from the said registry before registering of an artistic work. However, the Trade Marks Act does not provide any similar provisions relating to searching of copyrights before registering of a device mark. Hence, there is a one way verification process.
Now arises a key question. How should Indian Courts decide upon conflicts between the exclusive rights to commercially use a registered trade mark under Section 28 and the author’s right to copyrighted work under Section 17? How can the law ensure structural and judicial coherence between these two regimes so that one statute cannot be use to subvert the statutory scheme defenses of the other?
The issue is further compounded because the fair dealings provisions provided under Section 52 of the Copyright Act do not match with the fair usage provisions provided under Section 30 of the Trademarks Act. Some owners take advantage of this and use a strategy of claiming their rights under copyright over a mark.
This paper seeks to understand the main legal issue arising out of this statutory lacuna. Due to the lack of a corresponding verification provision in the Trade Marks Act, there are chances of conflicting ownership issues and conflicting decisions of Courts. There is also a chance for strategical abuse where owners could seek remedies under Copyright over a mark. This paper therefore recommends that we close this gap by creating mutual administrative oversight, creating clear priority rules based on actual copyright owners under Section 17, and providing statutory defenses under both the Acts.
Keywords: artistic work, device mark, Copyright Act, Trade Marks Act, reciprocal verification, Section 45(1).
