The Hymn That Sparked A Legal Battle: A Closer Look At Kruse Vs Johnson, 1898, 2 Q.B. 91
- IJLLR Journal
- Mar 2
- 1 min read
Richa Kapoor, Amity University
Proteek Motilal, Amity University
BENCH:
CJ. LORD RUSSELL
J. CHITTY, J. WRIGHT, J. DARLING,
J. CHANNELL, J. MATHEW
BENCH AND QUORUM
The leading judgment, which established the principles of judicial review, was delivered by Charles Frederick Lord Russell of Killowen. He served as the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales from 1894 to 1900.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The Incident and Initial Challenge (1898):
Mr. Kruse, a Salvation Army preacher, is arrested for singing hymns in a public place within 50 yards of a dwelling house. This likely happened in Kent, England, based on the involvement of the Kent County Council. He challenged the arrest, likely arguing that the bylaw is unreasonable.
Lower Court Proceedings (Unknown Date):
The case is likely heard in a magistrate's court, a lower court that deals with minor offenses.
The details of arguments presented and the lower court's decision are unclear.
Depending on the outcome, one of two scenarios might have unfolded:
1. Loss in Lower Court: If Mr. Kruse loses, he might choose to appeal the decision.
