Critically Examining The Structural And Practical Concerns In The Draft Arbitration & Conciliation (Amendment) Bill, 2024
Medha Anand Soni, National University of Study and Research in Law (NUSRL), Ranchi
ABSTRACT
India aspires to be a preferred seat of arbitration, yet its courts carry more than 5.6 crore pending cases, and arbitration is often as slow and litigious as the court process it was meant to replace. The Draft Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Bill 2024, released for consultation by the Department of Legal Affairs, builds on the recommendations of the Expert Committee chaired by Dr T.K. Viswanathan and aims to reduce court intervention and improve efficiency. This article examines whether the draft can deliver on those aims.
It analyses the draft’s principal proposals such as statutory recognition of emergency arbitration, fixed procedural timelines, the move from “place” to “seat” in section 20, and the creation of Appellate Arbitral Tribunals. It argues that while these changes address real weaknesses and bring the Act closer to the UNCITRAL Model Law, several are incompletely designed. The draft says little about how appellate tribunals are constituted, how their decisions will be made accessible, or how their independence will be guaranteed. Its strict time limits risk shutting out parties with genuine reasons for delay. Extending the ground of patent illegality to international commercial arbitration may deter foreign parties, and barring section 9 applications once proceedings begin leaves unclear how interim relief in aid of foreign-seated arbitrations over assets in India could be enforced.
The article contends that where the draft is vague, parties will return to the courts for answers, bringing back the delay and intervention the draft seeks to remove. It concludes with targeted recommendations to define how appellate tribunals are formed and safeguarded, allow a narrow power to excuse justified delay, reconsider the extension of patent illegality, and provide a clear route to enforceable interim relief.
