Reverse Engineering In Trade Secrets: A Comparative Analysis Of India's 2024 Bill And The EU Directive
Lalith Swetha, B.A.LL.B. (Hons.), Sastra University
ABSTRACT
Indian law treats reverse engineering as a fair way to learn a trade secret, but it has no statute to say so, relying instead on equity, confidence and contract, while the Law Commission's draft Protection of Trade Secrets Bill, 2024 would make it a lawful means of acquisition without defining the term. This leaves open whether a contract can switch that freedom off, and in a market where software and connected devices are sold in forms competitors can study, an unclear answer exposes both honest competitors and secret holders to risk. The paper argues that the Bill's reverse engineering rule cannot be read alone and must be tested against the Contract Act, the rules of evidence and the Copyright Act's software exceptions before it is enacted. Existing scholarship, including Lemley, Bone, Cohen and Lemley, broadly agrees that reverse engineering spreads know-how and keeps markets competitive, though it accepts limits where copying erases the first mover's lead. These works are largely American or concern the proposed EU Directive, and none compares the Indian draft Bill with the Directive or asks how contract terms, proof requirements and software decompilation exceptions interact in India.
This paper reads Section 4 of the Bill against Article 3 of the EU Directive and its Recitals 16 and 17, with brief reference to US law, to show that the Bill omits the Directive's recitals and its qualifier that a limiting duty be legally valid. It then tests the Bill against Section 27 of the Contract Act, the burden of proof under the Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, and Section 52(1)(aa) to (ac) of the Copyright Act, 1957, noting that India has no equivalent of Article 6(2) or Article 8 of the Software Directive. Because no Indian court has ruled on a clause prohibiting reverse engineering, several of its conclusions are predictions rather than settled law. The paper's contribution is to show how these layers fit together and where they leave gaps, so that Parliament can clarify the reach of contractual prohibitions, the allocation of proof and the later use of lawfully decompiled information.
Keywords: pre empt, interoperability, decompilation, directives.
