The Ownership Conundrum Of Genai Outputs: A Comparison Between The Rights Of The Prompter And That Of The Platform Through The Lens Of The Statutory And The Judicial Paradigms
Riddhi Yadav, Symbiosis Law School, Nagpur
INTRODUCTION: THE PARADOX OF OWNERSHIP – AI VS HUMAN
The structure of IP law has always been based on a single premise: creative expression is a strictly human activity. For centuries, copyright systems have been constructed to encourage human intellect, both economically and philosophically. However, with the sudden uproar of Large Language Models (LLMs) and more sophisticated diffusion models, this paradigm has been broken.
Generative Artificial Intelligence systems are not just about automating processes; they are about creating, abstracting, and making decisions creatively that are comparable and often superior to those of human authors. The legal system is thus caught up in a situation that has never been faced before: who owns the results produced by an AI platform? Where does the intellectual property lie between the end-user (the prompter) whose particular instructions led to the creation of the system and the platform (the developer) that created the architecture of the model, neural weights, and algorithmic layers used?
This inquiry goes beyond being a theoretical exercise and has significant economic consequences for the global digital economy. From being a curiosity to a tool that could impact entire industries, the absence of a clear law governing generative AI poses a significant threat to industry stability. The issue at the heart of this legal battle is an intricate mix of private contract law and statutory intellectual property regulations.
