Waning Authority: The Role Of The International Criminal Court And Its Institutional Inefficiencies In Recent Times
Dr. Satyabrata Mishra, Assistant Professor, NUSRL, Ranchi
ABSTRACT
The International Criminal Court (“ICC”) was created by the Rome Statute as a permanent court of last resort for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes and the crime of aggression. Since 2023 it has issued some of the most consequential arrest warrants in its history. They name the sitting head of state of a permanent member of the UN Security Council and the sitting Prime Minister of a close Western ally, and, in a rare case of real enforcement, a former head of state who was arrested and handed over within days of the warrant. This article looks at those developments next to the structural weaknesses that have sharpened at the same time: widespread non- cooperation and non-execution of warrants, coercive unilateral sanctions against the Court's own personnel, an unresolved jurisdictional gap over aggression, persistent budget pressure and, most recently, a governance crisis stemming from misconduct allegations against the Prosecutor himself. I argue that the Court's growing readiness to target powerful states has exposed its structural limits instead of resolving them, because it depends wholly on the cooperation of the very states it seeks to hold to account.
Keywords: International Criminal Court, Rome Statute, international criminal justice, State non-cooperation, complementarity, crime of aggression, institutional inefficiency.
