The Bar And Bench Relationship: How The Bar Protects The Bench And How The Bench Protects Democracy In India

Full Text Link

Aaryan Bansal & Prachi Sharma, B.A. LL.B., Vivekananda Institute of Professional Studies – TC, New Delhi, Affiliated to GGSIP University.

ABSTRACT

The relationship between the Bar and the Bench in India occupies a unique and often underappreciated place in the country's constitutional order. This paper examines that relationship across three broad dimensions: its constitutional foundations, the Bar's role in protecting judicial independence, and the judiciary's role in sustaining democratic governance. Drawing on constitutional provisions, landmark judgments, and significant historical episodes, the paper argues that the Bar and the Bench are not merely complementary institutions but mutually constitutive ones. Each depends on the other for legitimacy, effectiveness, and long-term survival.

The paper traces how provisions like Articles 50, 124, and 217 established the structural conditions for judicial independence, and how that independence was later tested, defended, and refined through cases like Kesavananda Bharati, ADM Jabalpur, and the Judges' Cases. It also examines how the judiciary, through constitutional review, fundamental rights jurisprudence, and electoral oversight, has actively protected democratic institutions from legislative and executive overreach.

The central argument is straightforward: democratic constitutionalism in India has endured not because of any single institution, but because of the ongoing, sometimes strained, but ultimately resilient relationship between a vigilant Bar and an independent Bench. That relationship, this paper suggests, remains one of India's most important and least celebrated democratic assets.

914. THE BAR AND BENCH RELATIONSHIP- HOW THE BAR PROTECTS THE BENCH AND HOW THE BENCH PROT

Download THE BAR AND BENCH RELATIONSHIP- HOW THE BAR PROTECTS THE BENCH AND HOW THE BENCH PROT • 341KB